The Phantom of the Not-On-This-Blogera.

This is the second post in a row I have tried to make about The Phantom of the Opera, and twice in a row, something happened with WordPress when I tried to post them. Both different issues. Both different Phantoms, even, and so I’m going to take this as a sign that I want to post anything about The Phantom of the Opera, I better make it short and sweet.

Andrew Lloyd Webber’s original PotO soundtrack was my freaking jam when I was younger. I even had the chance to see it performed live in Toronto on a family vacation, and tell me Sarah Brightman and Michael Crawford belting out about the music of the night and the point of no return. Creepy, atmospheric, perfect for pretending I could actually be a strong enough singer that a chemical-burned tragic hero might feel the need to cut chandeliers and steal me away to the sewers of Paris because he couldn’t live without my voice.

And then there’s the 1943 version with Claude Raines and the exquisite Susanna Foster, which I probably watched a million times when I was younger. I had the treat of watching it again not too long ago when my boyfriend, knowing it was a favorite I hadn’t seen in years, purchased a copy, and I was pleasantly shocked to realize that I still knew all the songs. Such a feast for the senses! Gorgeously rendered, lavishly performed, and those voices! Good lord, those voices! It’s not nearly as creepy or scary as the Webber version, but it’s such a heartfelt tragedy for me, and still one of my favorites.

I still haven’t seen the Lon Chaney version, if you can believe it. And I haven’t seen the 2004 Webber “reboot” with Emmy Rossum and Gerald Butler, and that…I don’t think seeing that is nearly as important as the Chaney one.

Are you much of a Phantom fan? Which is your favorite? And I’ll leave it at that before something else happens, and I fail to get a Phantom post up for the third time, at which point I’m going to think it’s just as good as the Scottish Play!


  1. I am SO much a Phantom fan. I was lucky enough to see a live performance in Atlanta. But I WASN’T lucky enough to see the Brightman/Crawford version. I would totally swoon to see Michael Crawford perform this. As hot as Gerard Butler is, after seeing the movie, I don’t think he really has the voice for the part. He was pretty good, but just not quite up to par.

    If you want to read a really good version of the phantom story, check out Susan Kay’s “Phantom”.

    • Ooh I’ll definitely add it to my (oh-so-lengthly) TBR list! I love a good twist on something familiar.

      I’m 95% sure that the one one we saw wasn’t Brightman or Crawford, either, but I was maybe 13 or 14 at the time, and it was a thrilling, enchanting experience regardless. So, so good.

  2. PoTC the new movie came out when I was in 7th grade and our chorus class did all the music. I had the Michael Crawford CD at home and listened constantly. Love it. Phantom is an amazing musical.

    • It truly is. I need to see if I can dig that CD up somewhere; I’m pretty sure it’s around here somewhere. My stepmom got me my own when she got tired of how often I “borrowed” hers!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s